Cartridge · AI analysis · Expert, rank 3

Hana SL Mk II: Analysis

AI analysis (research): successor to the Hana SL — low-output MC with Nude Shibata stylus, new tapered aluminium cantilever, brass top plate and 8 Ω Alnico generator from the Umami Blue and ML. Manufacturer data and international trade press, no listening test.

AI research Expert Index 82 / 100 Rank 3 in Expert Prices as of Oct. 2026
Hana SL Mk II, cartridge
Photo: manufacturer Hana · product photo for illustration only.
Hana SL Mk II (2/4) — manufacturer photo
Photo: manufacturer Hana · additional product photo.
Hana SL Mk II (3/4) — manufacturer photo
Photo: manufacturer Hana · additional product photo.
Hana SL Mk II (4/4) — manufacturer photo
Photo: manufacturer Hana · additional product photo.

Summary

Sound Vinyl BotPro Champion: Hana SL Mk II, Expert, Vinyl BotPro Index 82, Analysis 09/2026. AI assessment of the expected sound data, not a listening test.VinylCinationLevelExpertHana SL Mk IICartridge82Vinyl BotPro IndexSoundVinyl BotPro ChampionAnalysis (09/2026)www.VinylCination.de
82Vinyl BotPro Index · rank 3 (Expert)

The Hana SL Mk II replaces the Hana SL, which the manufacturer no longer offers. The Nude Shibata stylus remains; new are a tapered aluminium cantilever, cryo-treated yoke and pole pieces, a brass top plate with threaded holes and the 8 Ω generator with 30 µm copper wire from the Umami Blue and ML. Hana quotes 0.4 mV, 15–32,000 Hz, 2 g tracking force, 10 × 10⁻⁶ cm/dyn dynamic compliance and 8.6 g cartridge weight. US list price 850 $; in Europe it costs around 850 € (as of Oct. 2026, without guarantee).

Successor

Replaces the Hana SL, which Hana no longer offers. The SL Mk II is the official successor in the S series.

Assumptions

  • Requires an MC phono stage or step-up transformer for 0.4 mV
  • European price approx. 850 € as a guide (US list 850 $, as of Oct. 2026)
  • Medium-mass tonearm with suitable resonance for 8.6 g and 10 cu

Specifications (manufacturer)

Type / StylusMC, low output · Nude Shibata · tapered aluminium cantilever
Output / Impedance0.4 mV (1 kHz) · 8 Ω
Load / tracking force>80 Ω · 2 g
Weight8.6 g
Price guideapprox. €850 · US list US$850 · as of Oct. 2026 · without guarantee
Manufacturer specifications (Hana)
Manufacturer data sheet
TypeMoving coil, low output (LO-MC)
Stylus / cantileverShibata (nude) · tapered aluminium
Output / balance0.4 mV (1 kHz) · <1.5 dB (1 kHz)
Tracking force / trackability2 g · 70 µm at 2 g
Compliance (dynamic)10 × 10⁻⁶ cm/dyne
Channel separation / frequency response28 dB (1 kHz) · 15–32,000 Hz
Impedance / recommended load8 Ω (1 kHz) · >80 Ω
Weight / colour8.6 g · black
Warranty2 years
Price (manufacturer)US$850 (US list)

Source: Hana – official specifications · As of 18 October 2026 · subject to change by the manufacturer

Scores in detail

Technology / build
Nude Shibata, tapered alu cantilever, cryo parts
8.8
Features
Threaded top plate, 8.6 g · no stylus replacement
7.4
Expected performance
Press: dynamic, detailed, wide soundstage
9.0
Value for money
Shibata MC under 900 €
8.2
Total (guidance only)
Tier Expert · Vinyl BotPro Index 82
8.4

Vinyl BotPro Index: 82 · Index band Expert 70–84 · Guidance only, not a lab value.

Strengths

  • Nude Shibata stylus at an Expert price
  • Tapered aluminium cantilever with less mass at the tip
  • 8 Ω generator for many MC phono stages
  • Threaded brass top plate makes mounting easier

Weaknesses

  • Needs a good MC stage or a step-up transformer
  • Stylus not user-replaceable
  • According to Tracking Angle, not quite as open in the treble as more expensive cartridges
  • Around 100 $ more expensive than the old SL

Analysis: Hana SL Mk II in detail

Scope and sources

On the existing VinylCination page the Hana SL Mk II carries the title Sound Vinyl BotPro Champion in the Expert tier, with Vinyl BotPro Index 82 and rank 3 in that tier (analysis 09/2026). That ranking remains the live page’s; this long analysis adds named, checked international listening reports and the official manufacturer data. VinylCination has neither heard nor measured the SL Mk II itself.

Three independent specialist texts of the exact model are the pillars. Tracking Angle (Ken Redmond, 26 September 2024) compares the SL Mk II directly with the older Hana SL. The Absolute Sound (Andre Jennings, published 1 July 2025) lived with the SL Mk II over a longer period and also sets it against the predecessor. StereoNET (Chris Frankland, 2 April 2025) heard the SL Mk II and SH Mk II side by side on a Michell GyroDec SE with a Sorane SA1.2 tonearm and a Gold Note PH-5 phono stage. All three are print or online specialist publications, not forums, retailer pages or video channels.

The Hana manufacturer page (Hana SL MK II product page, retrieved 12 November 2026) states the ratings: low-output moving coil, nude Shibata on a tapered aluminium cantilever, 0.4 mV at 1 kHz, 8 ohms internal impedance, recommended load above 80 ohms, 2 g tracking force, 70 µm tracking ability, dynamic compliance 10 × 10⁻⁶ cm/dyn, 8.6 g weight, frequency response 15 to 32,000 Hz, US list price $850. The live table is left unchanged.

Hifi Pig appears on the existing page as a further source. We treat that title as a supplementary specialist text, not as a fourth carrying pillar, and invent no extra listening detail from it. Awards or mere product launches do not replace any of the three named listening reports.

Place in the range

The SL Mk II replaces the Hana SL, which the maker no longer lists. It remains the low-output model in the revised S series from Excel Sound in Japan. The predecessor’s nude Shibata stylus is retained but now sits on a new tapered aluminium cantilever. The generator, cryogenic treatment and threaded brass top plate come, according to Hana, from the Umami and M lines. Weight rises from about 5 g to 8.6 g.

The existing page places the SL Mk II in the Expert cartridge tier as Sound champion, with Index 82 just above the predecessor (Index 81). Comparison models on the live page are the high-output sister SH Mk II, the Dynavector DV 20X2A and the Ortofon 2M Black LVB 250 as the MM overall winner of the tier. This long analysis takes that order and does not recalculate the index.

Redmond stresses that this is not a mere refresh at a higher price; the number of changes could have justified marketing it as an entirely new model. Jennings calls the SL Mk II a worthy successor and a new over-achiever in the lower price class. Those are the judgements of those publications, not a listening score of VinylCination’s own.

Design and manufacturer data

StereoNET also sketches the brand background: Excel Sound has made cartridges since 1975, for a long time also under other names, and insists on in-house manufacture. That helps explain the price bracket, but it does not replace a listening report. Frankland places the choice of alnico in the generator in a line with other specialists who prefer that magnet sonically; that too remains a technical placing, not a measurement.

According to the maker and the unchanged live table, the SL Mk II is a low-output moving coil with a nude Shibata, a tapered aluminium cantilever, an alnico magnet and a cross coil of 30 µm copper wire, 8 ohms and 0.4 mV. Yoke, pole pieces and gold-plated pins are cryogenically treated. The body has a matt elastomeric coating and a brass top with threaded mounting holes. Hana states 2 g tracking force, 28 dB channel separation at 1 kHz, 10 cu compliance and 8.6 g system weight. The recommended load is above 80 ohms.

These figures are ratings, not measurements of our own. The live page and the manufacturer page of 12 November 2026 agree on output, impedance, weight and stylus profile. The US list price remains $850; the live page gives about €850 as a European guide (as of October 2026, without guarantee).

The higher weight and medium compliance are aimed at medium-mass tonearms. The threaded top makes mounting easier than on the older SL. The stylus is not user-replaceable. Redmond regrets that Hana did not adopt the Umami-series stylus guard; that is a handling criticism, not a sonic judgement.

Frankland mounted the SL Mk II and SH Mk II in a Sorane SA1.2 with a detachable headshell on a Michell GyroDec SE, Gold Note PH-5 phono stage, Audio Note Meishu Tonmeister amplifier, and Russell K Red150 Se or Audio Note AN-J LX Hemp loudspeakers. Redmond compared the SL and SL Mk II on two arms, at 1.95 g and 150 ohms for the Mk II versus 2 g and 400 ohms for the older SL, and also listened through more modest phono stages including an iFi Zen Phono and an AudioKultura Iskra 1. Jennings worked among others with Basis and Graham arms and kept the SL Mk II alongside the older SL and the Umami Red. Those chains stay with the respective reports.

What the specialist press heard and measured

In a direct comparison with the older SL, Redmond hears a clear step forward: a larger stage, more macro- and micro-dynamics, more open treble and better separation of instruments. The tapered cantilever and the lower tip mass are, for him, the central technical change. Overall the picture remains slightly warm; in his report the SL Mk II does not quite reach the last openness in the treble of more expensive cartridges. The differences between old and new SL remained audible for him even on much less costly phono stages, not only on a very expensive combination.

After the first session Jennings describes harmonic richness, high transparency to the recorded event and marked depth of soundstage when the recording contains it. Over the listening period the cartridge seemed calmer and more refined, without the usual ups and downs of a running-in phase. Against the older SL he names greater musical clarity, more convincing timing of transients and richer decays, plus more agile and deeper-reaching bass and a more neutral balance overall. He finds no offensive traits standing in the way of the music; the SL Mk II, in every case he heard, does the music justice.

Frankland hears the SL Mk II and SH Mk II as dynamic, detailed and musical. In his text the SL Mk II is the value recommendation provided a suitable MC stage or step-up is available; the SH Mk II at 2 mV is aimed at MM inputs. The phono stage is no afterthought for him: he describes an open, quiet picture without audible hiss, including on David Bowie’s “Ashes to Ashes”, but he stays clearly with a comparison of two Hana models and does not offer a measurement curve of his own. The live page already summarised these three lines in substance; we now assign them by name and date.

No laboratory frequency-response curve of the SL Mk II appears in these three texts in a form we could present as a measurement of our own. Compliance, output and separation remain manufacturer ratings. Where Redmond or Jennings describe the Mk II bass as deeper or more agile than that of the older SL, that is a listening observation against the predecessor, not a re-measurement of compliance.

Setup and system

At 0.4 mV the SL Mk II needs an MC phono stage with enough gain or a step-up transformer; Hana recommends a load above 80 ohms. The live page points to the phono-preamplifier list. Redmond’s 150 ohm load and Frankland’s work on the Gold Note PH-5 are examples from the reports, not a general loading rule from VinylCination.

The existing page records that Tracking Angle does not grant the Mk II the last treble openness of dearer cartridges and notes the roughly $100 uplift over the older SL. We take both as documented reservations and price figures from that report, not as a downgrading of our own. Jennings’s remark that the cartridge gained refinement over the listening period we likewise read as an observation of his sample over time, not as a general running-in rule for every unit.

8.6 g and medium compliance suit medium-mass tonearms. The threaded brass top makes mounting easier than on the older SL. Very light arms and MM-only inputs without a step-up are, on the live page, less suitable combinations; for those the SH Mk II with the same mechanics and 2 mV is offered, or the less expensive EL Mk II with an elliptical stylus.

The listening reports work with typical analogue repertoire and named turntables, not with a comparison restaged by VinylCination. That yields no statement about individual turntables on the list, only that the texts at hand describe the cartridge itself. Anyone who wants a user-replaceable stylus will not find one in this model.

Price and availability

The existing page gives about €850 as a guide and $850 as the US list, as of October 2026, without guarantee of day-to-day retail prices. Redmond quotes $850 for the Mk II against $750 for the older SL; the uplift is therefore documented, but not converted into current euro street prices. This long analysis does not recalculate Index 82 and does not make a buying appeal.

In the Expert tier the SL Mk II remains Sound champion. The price sits under €900 and thus under many Shibata moving coils of higher tiers. That is the live page’s placing, supported by the three named listening reports, not by a listening experience of our own.

What we do not use

VinylCination has not heard the SL Mk II itself and has not measured it. Manufacturer claims about cryogenic treatment and the tapered cantilever remain technical description so long as the sonic sequel is assigned to the listening reports. Forum posts, dealer copy and video channels do not replace the pillars. Listening notes on the older Hana SL serve only the comparison documented by Redmond and Jennings, not as a substitute pillar for the Mk II.

German specialist press alone would not suffice under t646u; with Tracking Angle, The Absolute Sound and StereoNET, three international listening texts of the exact model are available. We do not treat an EISA or other award text as a listening pillar.

Conclusion of the analysis

The Hana SL Mk II is a low-output moving coil with a nude Shibata on a tapered aluminium cantilever, 0.4 mV, 8 ohms, 8.6 g and 2 g tracking force. Tracking Angle (Ken Redmond, 26 September 2024) hears, against the older SL, a larger stage, more dynamics and better separation, with a slight warmth and without the last treble openness of dearer cartridges. The Absolute Sound (Andre Jennings, 1 July 2025) describes rich tone colour, transparency, deeper staging, more agile and deeper bass and a more neutral balance than the predecessor. StereoNET (Chris Frankland, 2 April 2025) calls the SL Mk II and SH Mk II dynamic, detailed and musical and favours the SL when an MC stage is available.

This long analysis supports the live page’s existing champion ranking with these three named international listening reports, without its own measurement and without a buying appeal. Limits remain the chains used in those reports and the decision not to treat forums or awards as a pillar.

Sources

  1. Tracking Angle, Ken Redmond, Hana SL MK II Cartridge, 26 September 2024: https://trackingangle.com/equipment/hana-sl-mk-ii-cartridge
  2. The Absolute Sound, Andre Jennings, Hana SL MK II Phono Cartridge, published 1 July 2025: https://www.theabsolutesound.com/articles/hana-sl-mk-ii-phono-cartridge/
  3. StereoNET, Chris Frankland, Hana SL Mk II & SH Mk II Moving Coil Cartridge Review, 2 April 2025: https://www.stereonet.com/reviews/hana-sl-mk-ii-sh-mk-ii-moving-coil-cartridge-review
  4. Hana, SL MK II manufacturer page, retrieved 12 November 2026: https://www.hanacartridges.com/products/hana-sl-mk-ii
  5. VinylCination, existing Hana SL Mk II product page (guide about €850, US list $850, as of October 2026; champion ranking Expert Sound, Index 82, rank 3).

Created by AI (Vinyl BotPro) from the sources named; no in-house listening tests or measurements. A detailed human fact-check is still outstanding.

Comparison models

Hana SH Mk IISame mechanics as high output (2 mV) for the MM input
Dynavector DV 20X2ALow-output MC from Japan, similar price class
Ortofon 2M Black LVB 250Overall winner of the tier, MM with Shibata, no MC gain needed

System matching

Works well with

  • MC phono stages or step-up transformers for 0.4 mV
  • Medium-mass tonearms (cartridge weight 8.6 g)
  • Listeners who want Shibata resolution without a Master budget

Less suited

  • Phono stages with an MM input only
  • Very light tonearms
  • Listeners who want a replaceable stylus

Vinyl in practice

At 0.4 mV the SL Mk II needs an MC phono stage with enough gain or a step-up transformer; Hana recommends a load above 80 Ω. The higher weight of 8.6 g suits medium-mass arms. Suitable phono stages: phono preamplifier top list.

Technology in detail

The SL Mk II belongs to Hana's revised S series (Excel Sound). The Nude Shibata stylus of the predecessor remains, but now sits on a new tapered aluminium cantilever that is stiffer and has less mass at the tip. Yoke, pole pieces and the gold-plated output pins are cryo-treated.

According to Hana, the generator comes from the Umami Blue and ML: Alnico magnet and cross coil with 30 µm copper wire, 8 Ω internal impedance. The body follows the M series, is damped with a matte elastomer coating and carries a brass top plate with threaded holes. This raises the weight from around 5 g to 8.6 g; Hana quotes 0.4 mV, 2 g tracking force, 70 µm trackability and 10 × 10⁻⁶ cm/dyn dynamic compliance.

What the specialist press says

In a direct comparison with the old SL, Tracking Angle hears a clear step forward: a larger soundstage, more macro and micro dynamics, more open treble and better separation of instruments; slightly warm overall, with compromises in ultimate treble openness. The Absolute Sound describes rich tone colours, high transparency and good depth layering, a more agile and deeper bass than the predecessor and a more neutral tuning. StereoNET calls the SL Mk II and SH Mk II dynamic, detailed and musical and sees the SL as the recommendation, provided a suitable MC stage is available. Hifi Pig highlights the quiet background and the dynamics.

Recurring pattern: clearly better than the old SL, musical and dynamic, with slight warmth and without the final refinement of the Umami models. These are magazine verdicts, summarised by Vinyl BotPro — no listening experience of our own.

Who is it for?

phono stage

An MC stage with around 60 dB gain or a step-up transformer is a must; the load should be above 80 Ω. Suitable devices are in the phono top list.

Tonearm

8.6 g and medium compliance suit medium-mass arms. The threaded brass top plate makes mounting easier than with the old SL.

Alternatives

If you have no MC input, choose the SH Mk II with the same mechanics; if you want to spend less, the EL Mk II with elliptical stylus.

The special features of this analysis

This AI analysis brings together manufacturer specifications, technical data and the verdicts of the specialist press in a compact assessment. It shows where the sources agree, which strengths come up again and again, and which system the product suits best. Prices as of Oct. 2026.

How the score comes about

Vinyl BotPro Index 0–100; technology/build, features, expected performance and price/performance are weighted 25/20/25/30. Expert is typically ~70–84. It takes over its predecessor's place (index 81) and sits just above it with 82: the international specialist press consistently describes the Mk II as a clear step forward in dynamics, soundstage and bass definition, while the price rises only moderately. No listening test. Details on weighting · Methodology.

Sources

Created by Vinyl BotPro (AI) · AI analysis · As of 18.10.2026 · Corrections: info@vinylcination.de · Prices without guarantee.